Soupcat's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[A Newgrounds Commercial]

Seeing that I loved the animations concept and execution, I feel bad for even mentioning this, but it has to be said; It doesn't have a commercial feel to it.
It feels more like a standalone cartoon than a promotion or advertisement for Newgrounds.

You said that you kept it short to "keep the commercial vibe", but keeping it short isn't enough. A cartoon needs to have more design/typography features to come across as a commercial.
Please don't take this as negative criticism, I'm simply criticizing the subject you submitted it under.
It's still probably one of the best submissions in the commercial contest so far and I bet you'll do great.

Goddamnit I always wanted to see Newgrounds in Real Life city format. You nailed it dude. Great job.

Jonimator responds:

Ya I can definitely see your point, I've really gotten used to working in the style of standalone cartoons over the years. Glad you liked it nonetheless! Thanks for the review!

[Geordie Gore]

its kinda gay

I LIKE IT

Plebs responds:

It is very gay and now i should make something totally not gay.

[Flash is useless]

Probably got out of the under judgement because you picked a concept that a lot of people enjoy seeing I guess.
It was the first one that I layed eyes upon when I went to the "latest movies" section. So ya, theres that.

Anyway, I was hoping to see a little bit better art work or whatever, but the animation in itself is nice. Its smooth and has a nice pacing to it.
Too bad the art was sub par. Anyway, Im looking forward to seeing new things from you! Keep going and don't stop dude!

Daker777NG responds:

Looks like my "making catchy thumbnails and titles" skills work for now, also the art is a little bit off because i'm keeping it simple so it's easier to animate, i tryied to make more complex things before and it was a headache, and never finished it xD
Also thank you for the feedback :)

[DayZ Fail]

Dont say shit like "worship me" or whatever. Not even as a joke. It makes you look arrogant and you don't get to be arrogant in your first animation. Try staying humble about your work until you get better.

Jimbobasaur responds:

Thanks, but I was only reflecting on how most popular animators have a 'God' like status, I wasn't trying to be arrogant :) Thanks for the comment :D

[Brominoe Effect]

wilhelm screen

Kiigen responds:

Yep. Which guessing from your one sentence and 2.5 star review.... that makes the animation mediocre? I don't get it.

[Happy Tree Friends (Ep.1)]

fake and gay

HTFmondo responds:

Actually, quite real. Our Team at Mondo, have decided to upload our videos on Newgrounds! So we can share our videos with different audiences! We do not appreciate your unkind gesture, and judgment. Please feel free to blog us or visit our website at:

Our Site
www.mondomedia.com

YouTube
www.youtube.com/user/MondoMedia

Thank You For Your Time

[Barbequestyle IV]

dude, your penis is going the wrong way °O°

Bbqbeefburgerman responds:

My penis is fine

[Boy Gamers]

that fucking background music. I FUCKING HATE THAT BACKGROUND MUSIC. Theres a whole audio portal to chose from.

thekiwi responds:

ok.

[We're all going to die!]

i feel like ive seen this before somewhere

rhys510 responds:

nope :P

[PikaPoop]

don't steal styles pls, it's not cool bro

JoeliusNG responds:

man... I have my own style, what exactly am I copying?